Newsreal: Bibi the bungler
It is being called the worst fiasco in the history of
Israel's once-vaunted intelligence service, the Mossad. It raises,
once again, serious questions about Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu's mental fitness, provoked unprecedented expressions of
disgust from the Clinton administration and left experienced
observers to wonder what other disastrous pratfalls the Israeli
leader has in store for the dying Middle East peace
process.
By Jonathan Broder - - - - - - -
- - -
October 07, 1997
| WASHINGTON -- it is being called the worst fiasco in
the history of Israel's once-vaunted intelligence service, the
Mossad. It raises, once again, serious questions about Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's mental fitness. It provoked
unprecedented expressions of disgust from the Clinton administration
-- "we loathe him," one White House official remarked -- and left
experienced observers to wonder what other disastrous pratfalls the
Israeli leader has in store for the dying Middle East peace
process.
The fiasco, which ranks right up there with
the CIA's anti-Castro exploding cigars, involves a botched attempt
by Mossad agents last month to assassinate Khaled Mashaal, a
political leader of Hamas in Amman, Jordan. Jordan, you may
remember, is one of the only Arab countries that has signed a peace
treaty with Israel, and King Hussein, despite increasingly
pro-Islamic sentiment in the desert kingdom, has served as Israel's
most consistent apologist and defender in the Arab world.
In return for such largess, Prime Minister
Netanyahu last month personally ordered the hit on Jordanian soil --
just one month before scheduled parliamentary elections there -- in
retaliation for recent Hamas bombings in Jerusalem. Calling the
attempt a "reckless betrayal" of the Israeli-Jordanian peace treaty,
King Hussein demanded -- and got -- the release of Sheikh Ahmed
Yassin, Hamas' spiritual leader, who was serving a life sentence in
an Israeli jail. Ten thousand "delirious" supporters turned out to
greet Yassin Monday in the Gaza Strip. Hamas now appears even
stronger than ever, while Netanyahu, in the words of the Associated
Press, was left "struggling to explain why he struck a deal with the
sponsors of bombings against Israeli civilians."
"I'd be laughing my ass off if this was
happening in somebody else's country," Israeli columnist Zeev
Chafets said. "Let's not forget that Netanyahu, the putz who ordered
up this farce, is the same guy who controls Israel's nuclear
arsenal. Watching him screw up used to be entertaining. Now it's
scary."
Strategically, the botched assassination
already has caused severe damage to Israel's relations with Jordan.
Zeev Schiff, military editor for the Haaretz newspaper, said
Netanyahu's choice of Amman as the locale for the assassination
attempt was "akin to carrying out an operation of this kind in
Washington or some other friendly capital."
Worse, the affair comes at a time when
Netanyahu has been urging PLO leader Yasser Arafat to crack down on
Hamas. As a result of the fiasco, Arafat already has halted his
crackdown while receiving Yassin as a hero. With the expected
release of more Hamas prisoners in exchange for the two captured
Mossad agents, Israel's security problems can be expected to
grow.
The details of the assassination attempt
itself, pieced together from reports in the Israeli and Jordanian
press and Salon interviews with U.S., Jordanian and Israeli
officials, read like a Woody Allen parody of a cheap spy
thriller.
The day two Hamas suicide bombers struck at
Jerusalem's Mahane Yehuda market in Jerusalem on July 30, killing 16
Israelis, the Israeli cabinet met and voted to hunt down Hamas
leaders wherever they could be found. According to Israeli
officials, the broadly worded decision authorized the Mossad to
begin drawing a number of plans to eliminate Hamas officials in a
number of Arab capitals.
Sometime in late August, Mossad chief Dani
Yatom presented Netanyahu with several assassination blueprints,
including plans to liquidate Hamas officials in Damascus and Amman,
the officials said. According to Israeli press reports, Netanyahu,
who has publicly pointed the finger of responsibility at
Damascus-based Hamas leaders for previous bombings, ruled out
proposals for operations in the Syrian capital because they were too
risky. But he did give the green light to hit Mashaal, described by
Israeli and American experts as a relatively moderate Hamas
political operative.
The method chosen to kill Mashaal was a
lethal nerve toxin to be delivered through his skin. Late in
September, two Israeli agents checked into the Intercontinental
Hotel in Amman with Canadian passports that identified them as Shawn
Kendall, 28, and Barry Beads, 36. On Sept. 25, the pair trailed
Mashaal to his office, and as the Hamas official walked into the
building, one of the agents came up behind him and held a device to
Mashaal's left ear that stung him with the poison. The two agents
then fled on foot.
Mashaal's bodyguard, an expert in martial
arts, ran after them, but the Israelis jumped into a waiting vehicle
and drove off. The bodyguard then flagged down a private car and
gave chase as the two cars careened around corners at high speed.
Suddenly, the first car stopped and the two Israelis jumped out,
fleeing again on foot. Mashaal's bodyguard sprang from his own car
and caught one of the Israelis by the back of his shirt.
Western and Jordanian press reports,
quoting eyewitnesses, say the Israeli turned around and hit the
bodyguard in the head with a blunt object, opening a wound that
later required 18 stitches. Despite the blow, the bodyguard knocked
out the Israeli with a single punch, pounced on the second Israeli,
knocked him senseless and threw him down on an embankment. By this
time, Jordanian security officers arrived and hauled the battered
Israelis to a nearby police station.
Meanwhile, Mashaal began to feel the effect
of the nerve toxin. Experiencing difficulty breathing and
uncontrollable vomiting, he was rushed to hospital. By the next
morning, Jordanian press reports said, Mashaal was unconscious,
breathing through a respirator and running a temperature of 102 that
did not respond to any treatment.
By this time, according to Jordanian
officials, the two assailants had admitted under interrogation --
and had confessed on videotape -- that they worked for the Mossad.
Canadian intelligence officials had examined their passports and
determined they were forged.
Enter King Hussein. According to a the
semi-official Jordanian Al-Rai newspaper, the monarch called
Netanyahu demanding to obtain the antidote to the poison. Hussein
warned Netanyahu that if Mashaal died, the two captured Israeli
agents would be tried in public and hanged, and that Jordan would
sever diplomatic relations with Israel. Netanyahu reportedly
refused. The king then called President Clinton in Washington,
urging him to pressure Netanyahu for the antidote. After a call from
Clinton, Netanyahu finally relented, and a Mossad official
administered the antidote, saving Mashaal's life. After the call,
Clinton reportedly remarked bout Netanyahu: "I can't stand that man.
He's impossible." Another senior White House official confirmed the
remark, adding: "We loathe him."
The next day, Netanyahu, accompanied by
several government ministers and security officials, secretly flew
to Amman to demand the release of their captured agents. The
normally gracious king refused to see them. But Hussein instructed
his brother, Crown Prince Hassan, to tell the Israelis that the
price of the agents' freedom would be high. In order to soothe the
Islamic opposition in Jordan in advance of November's parliamentary
election, Hassan said, the Israelis would have to release Sheikh
Yassin. He also indicated the Israelis probably would have to
release more Hamas prisoners before the agents could be
returned.
Hassan then flew to Washington, where he
showed President Clinton, Vice President Al Gore and Secretary of
State Madeleine Albright reams of evidence against the Israeli
agents, including the damning videotape. He also appealed to the
president to take a firmer hand in preventing the disintegration of
the peace process and told the Washington Post that he still feels
"waves of nausea" when he thinks of Netanyahu's actions and their
consequences for Middle East peace.
"I cannot understand how the Israeli prime
minister thinks, and this causes me great worry," King Hussein told
the London-based Al-Hayat
Predictably, the Labor Party opposition is
screaming for Netanyahu's resignation, and a number of conservative
columnists and retired generals have joined the chorus. A public
opinion poll published Monday shows Netanyahu with a 32 percent
approval rating among Israeli Jews, his lowest rating since he took
office in June 1996.
But as in previous crises, Netanyahu is
protected by his right-wing coalition, which commands a 68-seat
majority in the 120-seat parliament. Netanyahu's opponents would
need the support of 61 parliamentary deputies to topple his
government in a vote of no-confidence and 81 votes to remove him
personally.
"There's going to be a lot of screaming,
but I can't see Netanyahu falling on his sword," Chafets said.
"Sadly, I fear the only way he's going is resting on his sword, like
a kabob."
salon.com
- - - - - - - - - - - -
About the
writer Jonathan Broder is Salon's Washington
correspondent.
Sound Off Send us a Letter to the
Editor
This is a
republished copy of an original Salon article.
You can view
this story in its original format.
|